The IOTD/TP process is continuously tweaked and improved in order to ensure that the selection of the Image of the Day and Top Picks as is as unbiased and fair as possible.
I'm sure most of you know how it works by now, after having read the IOTD/TP Manifesto. Those who haven't yet, are kindly invited to do so.
The current incarnaton of the process has evolved during 7 years of listening to feedback, ironing out kinks, and making informed decisions on the direction of the IOTD/TP.
In response to recent feedback, a few improvements have been applied to the selection process:
When an image is dismissed by 5 individual team members, that image is removed from the process. This ensures that the six least knowledgeable members of the team cannot do "damage" but selecting a Top Pick that doesn't meet AstroBin's quality standards.
The submission process changed from implicit to explicit. Before this change, all images were entered in the IOTD/TP process automatically upon publication (unless the photographer had opted out in their settings). Now, images need to be submitted explicitly using the Actions menu, within two days of its publication. You are still able to choose to submit all your new images automatically, if you feel confident. 😊
The selection queues where the team members operate have received a few usability and performance improvements.
Together, points 1 and 2 above ensure that the volume of images that the team has to process is more manageable. This leads to the members of the IOTD/TP team spending more time evaluating each image.